top of page

Your Charitably-Inclined Client Just Signed an LOI. You Have 90 Days.

Writer: JT Hardcastle
JT Hardcastle
5 days ago
6 min read
Cool dawn light from a tall window falling across an empty conference table, a closed folder at one end

A client who owns a regional engineering company forwards you a four-page PDF on a Thursday afternoon. A strategic buyer has offered a number for 100% of the stock, with 75 days of exclusivity and a target closing at the end of the quarter. He adds one line at the bottom of his email: he and his wife have always wanted to put a meaningful piece of this into a charitable vehicle, and he assumes you can sort that out at tax time.


Tax time is the problem. The return you file next spring will record, accurately, whatever happened in the next 90 days. It cannot change what happened. That is the boundary described in Where the Tax Return Stops and the Plan Begins, and a letter of intent is the point where it becomes a deadline.


Why the Gift Has a Shelf Life


The LOI itself is usually non-binding apart from exclusivity and confidentiality. That is the useful fact and also the misleading one. Your client has not sold anything, so the gain is not yet his, and a gift of appreciated stock made today can still be a completed gift of an asset, not an assignment of income. The window is open because the sale has not yet hardened into something the donee is bound to complete.


How long it stays open is a facts-and-circumstances question, and the case law has moved in the direction you would not want.


The older line of authority, Rev. Rul. 78-197 and Palmer, taxed the sale proceeds to the donor only if the charity was legally bound, or could be compelled by the corporation, to sell or surrender the shares at the time of the gift. In Rauenhorst v. Commissioner, the donors gave warrants to charities in the days before a sale agreement was signed, the merger closed shortly after, and the Tax Court held for the taxpayers. The Journal of Accountancy's March 2003 write-up reads that as a bright line: no binding obligation at the time of the gift, no income to the donor.


The Tax Court has since been less categorical. In Dickinson, T.C. Memo. 2020-128, a CFO gave closely held stock to a donor advised fund sponsor that redeemed the shares soon afterward. The court found for the taxpayers because the redemption was not practically certain at the moment of the gift, and no vote or agreement existed that fixed it. The standard it applied asks whether the transaction was a fait accompli, not whether anyone had signed.


Then came Estate of Hoensheid. As ACTEC Fellows described the case on an ACTEC Foundation podcast, the donor had no legal obligation to sell when he made the gift, and the court said so. It still taxed the gain to him, because regulatory approvals were in hand, corporate approvals were done, and a single non-substantive item remained open in the purchase agreement. The sale was a foregone conclusion. The speakers also noted that the donor lost the deduction because the appraisal came from an unqualified appraiser, which is a second, separate way to be wrong.


Read together, the three cases tell you the same thing in different registers. The further the deal moves past the LOI toward signed documents and cleared approvals, the less a gift of the stock looks like a gift of an asset. Your client's best date for the gift is earlier than his lawyer's calendar suggests.


What Has to Happen in the First 30 Days


Most of the work is front-loaded because most of it has long lead times and none of it can be done after the purchase agreement is effectively settled.


- The intent conversation. What does he want the charitable money to do, how much, and over what period? Do this before anyone proposes a vehicle. A client who says "meaningful" usually has a number in mind that he has not said aloud. - Entity and stock check. For a C corporation selling stock, a gift of shares is available in principle. If the company is an S corporation, bringing a tax-exempt shareholder into the pass-through carries its own treatment of the income that flows to the charity, and that should be reviewed by counsel before anyone drafts a gift. Asset deals, earnouts, and rollover equity each change the answer again. - Whether the sponsor will take the stock. Donor advised fund sponsors and private foundations do not accept closely held shares automatically. Many require a review period, transfer documents, and a representation about the buyer, and the review runs on the sponsor's schedule, not the client's. - A qualified appraisal, from a qualified appraiser. For closely held stock above the Form 8283 thresholds, the deduction depends on it. Order it now. The LOI price is a data point, not an appraisal, and the buyer's number will be examined later by someone who was not at the table. - Deal counsel in the loop. The purchase agreement language, the timing of the gift, and any representations about the donee all sit with the attorney. He needs to know the gift exists before he drafts around it.


Your Lane and the Other Lanes


You hold the pieces nobody else has: basis, holding period, the client's projected AGI for the year of closing, and what the return will look like under the 2026 rules. The 30% AGI limit for long-term appreciated property given to a public charity, the five-year carryforward for the excess, the 0.5% floor on itemized charitable deductions, and the 35% cap on the benefit for top-bracket givers all affect how large a gift makes sense and in which year. That modeling is yours.


Gift mechanics, sponsor acceptance, and the sequencing against a closing date belong to someone who does it often. The purchase agreement belongs to the lawyer. None of these is a lane you need to move into. The difficulty is that three people hold three parts of one plan, and the client is relaying messages between them.


That is the pattern we described in Referral or Partnership: Two Very Different Outcomes for Your Client. It is worse on a charitable sale because the deadline is external. A client who hears "talk to a specialist about the charitable side" in week one and meets him in week five has already lost most of the window.



Most firms find where their advice stops in the middle of a client conversation, not before it. A sale on a 75-day exclusivity clock is a poor time to learn that the charitable question belongs to nobody.


A Boundary Conversation is 30 minutes with JT and Luke. No pitch, no client names required, and a clear map of where your firm's advice currently stops.




Days 31 to 90


Once the gift is made, the work shifts to keeping it clean. The donee should hold the shares as its own, with no pre-arranged redemption understood between the client, the buyer, and the sponsor. The record should show the timing: the gift documents, the transfer, the acknowledgment, and the point at which each was completed, set against the date the purchase agreement was signed. Take the date of the gift and the date the sale became practically certain, and write both down while the facts are fresh.


At closing, the client will want to know what he can still do. Cash given after the sale is a different transaction with a different set of limits, and it does not recover the gain avoided on stock. A donor advised fund funded with proceeds gives the family a vehicle and a year of deductions, but it is not the same as a gift made before the sale. We covered the sequencing in The 90-Day Charitable Planning Window Before a Business Sale, which is written for the owner and which you can forward to him. If the stock qualifies, QSBS, DAFs, and the Stack Most CPAs Never Build covers what happens when the exclusion and the charitable gift are planned together.


Your return then does its job. It reports the gift, the deduction, the carryforward, and the gain on the shares the client sold. If the plan was built in the first 30 days, the return records a plan. If it was not, the return records a transaction.


The Judgment Call


Gallup's 2024 study of U.S. business owners, funded by JPMorganChase and the Kauffman Foundation, found that 74% of employer businesses plan to sell, transfer, or go public. Some share of your book is on that path now. Some of those owners have mentioned giving in a meeting you remember and have not mentioned since.


Choose one of those clients this week. Ask whether a letter of intent would find him with a charitable plan or without one. Then decide whether the answer is a conversation you start now, a document you hand him to read, or a call you make to a specialist before he asks. That decision is yours to make, and it costs far less in week one than in week ten.



You do not need to build a new capability to solve this for a client. You need one call to see whether a partnership does it better than a referral would.


The question is whether your client's charitable intent reaches a plan before it reaches a closing table.




J.T. Hardcastle is a Partner at Sage & Main who helps families and business owners align their wealth with their values through tax-smart planning and intentional generosity.

Comments


bottom of page